Comparison of direct measurements of sea ice thickness and snow height, CryoSat-2 observations and PIOMAS numerical estimates
https://doi.org/10.30758/0555-2648-2020-66-3-337-348
Abstract
The paper presents the results of comparison of contact measurements of ice thicknesses and snow heights performed at the points of the hydrological stations of the “Transarktika-2019” expedition in April 2019 north of Franz-Josef Land archipelago, with altimetry observations of the Cryosat-2 satellite and numerical estimates of the PIOMAS (Pan-Arctic numerical Ice and Ocean Modeling system and data Assimilation). A significantly better correspondence is predictably shown between the variability of the ice thickness directly measured and observed using the CryoSat-2 satellite than that for the numerical PIOMAS system estimates. A trial correction of the algorithm for calculating the ice thickness by replacing the climatic values of the ice density, snow density and height with data from direct measurements also predictably improves the quality of calculating the ice thickness from satellite observations. The mean / route mean square differences obtained for ice thicknesses (+44/+96 cm for uncorrected and +30/+95 cm for corrected CryoSat-2 satellite, –14/+81 cm for PIOMAS system) and snow height (–4/+12 cm for CryoSat-2 satellite, –15/+12 cm for PIOMAS system) show the scale of uncertainty in estimating sea ice thickness and snow height for areas dominated by medium and thick first-year ice.
An anomaly of the ice thicknesses observed during the expedition is given in comparison with the background characteristics based on historical ice charting data for 1970s — 1990s, earlier High-Arctic aircraft “Sever” expeditions during 1950s — 1970s and the stated remote observations and numerical estimates for 2000s — 2019. Comparison shows that the AARI expedition was actually carried out in one of the most favorable years for ice research in the last decade for this region — the average ice thickness in April 2019 was 15 — 28 cm higher than that for the interval 2011 — 2019 with a slightly lower (1 — 2 cm) height of the snow cover. In the earlier period of the 1970 — 1990s this area was characterized by significantly thicker old ice with characteristic thicknesses ~ 60 cm more than in April 2019.
Keywords
CryoSat-2,
ice freeboard,
ice thickness,
in situ observations,
PIOMAS,
snow height,
“Transarktika-2019”
Supporting agencies: This work was funded by the RFBR grant № 18-05-60048.
About the Authors
V. M. Smolyanitsky
State Scientific Center of the Russian Federation Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
A. B. Turyakov
State Scientific Center of the Russian Federation Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
K. V. Filchuk
State Scientific Center of the Russian Federation Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
I. E. Frolov
State Scientific Center of the Russian Federation Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
Russian Federation
St. Petersburg
References
1. Frolov I.E., Ivanov V.V., Filchuk K.V., Makshtas A.P., Kustov V.Yu., Mahotina I.A., Ivanov B.V., Urazgildeeva A.V., Syoemin V.L., Zimina O.L., Krylov A.A., Bogin V.A., Zakharov V.Yu., Malyshev S.A., Gusev E.A., Baryshev P.E., Pilgaev S.V., Kovalev S.M., Turyakov A.B. Transarktika-2019: winter expedition in the Arctic Ocean on the R/V “Akademik Tryoshnikov”. Problemy Arktiki i Antarktiki. Arctic and Antarctic Research. 2019, 65 (3): 255 — 274. [In Russian].
2. Meredith M., Sommerkorn M., Cassotta S., Derksen C., Ekaykin A., Hollowed A., Kofinas G., Mackintosh A., Melbourne-Thomas J., Muelbert M.M.C., Ottersen G., Pritchard H., Schuur E.A.G. Polar Regions. IPCC Special Report on the Ocean and Cryosphere in a Changing Climate [Pörtner H.-O., Roberts D.C., Masson-Delmotte Zhai V., P., Tignor M., Poloczanska E., Mintenbeck K., Alegría A., Nicolai M., Okem A., Petzold J., Rama B., Weyer N.M. (eds.)]. Available at: https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/3/2019/11/07_SROCC_Ch03_FINAL.pdf (accessed 01.09.2020).
3. Ivanova N., Pedersen L.T., Tonboe R.T., Kern S., Heygster G., Lavergne T., Sørensen A., Saldo R., Dybkjær G., Brucker L., Shokr M. Inter-comparison and evaluation of sea ice algorithms: towards further identification of challenges and optimal approach using passive microwave observations. The Cryosphere. 2015, 9: 1797 — 1817.
4. Liu Y., Key J., Wang X., Tschudi M. Multidecadal Arctic sea ice thickness and volume derived from ice age. The Cryosphere. 2020, 14: 1325 — 1345.
5. Systematic observation requirements for satellite-based data products for climate (2011 update). GCOS — 154. Geneve, GCOS Secretariat, 2011: 127.
6. Laxon S.W., Giles K.A., Ridout A.L., Wingham D.J., Willatt R., Cullen R., Kwok R., Schweiger A., Zhang J., Haas C. CryoSat-2 estimates of Arctic sea ice thickness and volume. Geophys. Res. Lett. 2013, 40: 732 — 737.
7. Ricker R.; Hendricks S., Helm V., Skourup H., Davidson M. Sensitivity of CryoSat-2 Arctic sea-ice freeboard and thickness on radar-waveform interpretation. The Cryosphere. 2014, 8 (4): 1607 — 1622.
8. Hendricks S., Ricker R. Product User Guide & Algorithm Specification — AWI CryoSat-2 Sea Ice Thickness version 2.2. AWI. 2019: 54.
9. Zhang J., Rothrock D.A. Modeling global sea ice with a thickness and enthalpy distribution model in generalized curvilinear coordinates. Mon. Weather Rev. 2003, 131: 845–861.
10. Zhang J., Rothrock D. A Thickness and Enthalpy Distribution Sea-Ice Model. J. Phys. Ocean. 2001, 31: 2986 — 3001.
11. Buzuev A.Ya., Dubovtsev V.F., Zakharov V.F., Smirnov V.I. Usloviya plavaniya sudov vo l’dakh morei severnogo polushariya. Navigation conditions in the sea of the Northern Hemisphere. Moscow: GUNIO MO USSR, 1988: 280 p. [In Russian].
12. Historical collection of the Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute detailed ice charts of the Arctic Ocean for 1933—1992 in the WMO SIGRID exchange format. World Data Center SeaIce — Global Digital Sea Ice Data Bank. Available at: http://wdc.aari.ru/datasets/d0001/north/aari (accessed 01.09.2020).
13. Historical collection of the US National Ice Center Northern Hemisphere detailed ice charts for 1972—1994 in the WMO SIGRID exchange format // World Data Center Sea-Ice — Global Digital Sea Ice Data Bank. Available at: http://wdc.aari.ru/datasets/d0001/north/nic/sigrid (accessed 01.09.2020).
14. Grachev K.I., Konstantinov Yu.B.. Vysokoshirotnie vozdushnie ekspeditsii Sever. High-latitude aircraft expeditions “Sever”. St. Petersburg: Gidrometeoizdat, 2000: 176 p. [In Russian].
15. Romanov I.P. Morphometric Characteristics of Ice and Snow in the Arctic Basin: Aircraft Landing Observations from the Former Soviet Union, 1928—1989, Version 1. Boulder, Colorado USA. NSIDC: National Snow and Ice Data Center. doi: 10.7265/N5B8562T
Review
For citations:
Smolyanitsky V.M., Turyakov A.B., Filchuk K.V., Frolov I.E. Comparison of direct measurements of sea ice thickness and snow height, CryoSat-2 observations and PIOMAS numerical estimates. Arctic and Antarctic Research. 2020;66(3):337-348. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.30758/0555-2648-2020-66-3-337-348
Views:
893
Email this article 
